Court orders landowner to honour development agreement, dismisses fraud counterclaim

LexBru

The High Court has ruled in favour of WYWY Contractor in a dispute over a land development agreement, ordering tDayangku Rosinah binti Pengiran Bakar to comply with the agreement after finding that her defence of fraudulent misrepresentation had not been established.

Judicial Commissioner Edward Timothy Starbuck Woolley delivered the judgment on November 5 in Civil Suit No. 76 of 2021, following hearings on October 22 and November 2, 3 and 4.

The dispute concerned a 5.003-acre leasehold property at Kampong Sungai Hanching, Mukim Berakas (B), which was originally owned by the defendant’s father, Pengiran Bakar bin Pengiran Haji Sulaiman. The development agreement was entered into between the plaintiff and the previous owner on March 21, 2013, with the latter’s rights and obligations subsequently transferred to the defendant through a novation agreement dated September 4, 2018.

Under the agreement, WYWY Contractor undertook to bear the cost of constructing five semi-detached houses, which would remain the owner’s property, and to pay the agreed sum of BND380,000.

The plaintiff sought specific performance after the defendant failed to execute the necessary documents to transfer ownership of Plot X to a purchaser.

In her defence and counterclaim, the defendant alleged that the agreement had been negotiated on the basis of a false representation that approximately two acres of the land could not be developed because of the hilly terrain and the need for sloping works.

She claimed the representation had fraudulently induced her and her father to accept a smaller share of the development than they had originally wanted. Had they known the entire land could be developed, they would not have agreed to receive five semi-detached houses and BND170,000 instead of six detached properties.

The defendant’s husband, Asmahkhan bin Mulkiaman, testified that he had been involved in discussions over the land’s development and had helped obtain approvals and engage surveyors and contractors for earthworks, levelling and sloping works.

He said the plaintiff’s position that the whole property could not be developed had been conveyed to him during negotiations through an intermediary, Pengiran Martini, and repeated by a representative of the plaintiff.

However, Pengiran Martini denied representing that the land could not be developed, saying the issue was whether developing the difficult portion would be commercially viable.

The judge preferred her evidence, finding it more likely that the plaintiff had conveyed that developing the 1.2-acre Plot X would be difficult or economically unrealistic, rather than impossible.

The court found that the defendant had failed to produce expert evidence showing that Plot X could be developed or that the plaintiff knew this when the agreement was made.

The subsequent sale of Plot X in 2019 and the reference to “Phase 2” on an attached plan were insufficient to establish that the original representation was false. There was also no evidence of the development intended by the purchaser or that the plaintiff would benefit from it beyond the purchase price.

The judge therefore found that the defendant had not established that the representation was false or that the plaintiff’s representative, Thien, knew it to be untrue under sections 17 and 18 of the Contracts Act, Cap 106.

The court also considered section 19 of the Act, which provides that an agreement is not voidable for misrepresentation or fraudulent silence where the affected party had the means of discovering the truth through ordinary diligence.

The judge found that the defendant and her husband had the experience and means to seek advice from surveyors or other experts about the development potential of the land, but had apparently not done so.

Appellate Court Justice Edward Timothy Starbuck Woolley consequently entered judgment for WYWY Contractor on the relief sought under the development agreement, dismissed the defendant’s counterclaim and ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff’s costs on the usual taxed basis, unless agreed. The court declined to award indemnity costs.

Eugene Loh Jit Kuan and Anlan Hee Tze Khow of Messrs Yusof Halim & Partners represented WYWY Contractor, while Sheikh Noordin Sheikh Mohammad of Messrs Sheikh Noordin Mohammad & Associates represented the defendant.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top