
A Singapore District Court has dismissed a passenger’s negligence claim against a private-hire driver who applied emergency brakes after a chicken crossed the road, finding that the driver had acted reasonably in the circumstances.
In grounds of decision issued on November 18, District Judge Jonathan Ng Pang Ern ruled that the driver was not responsible for the incident on February 19, 2024, in which the passenger claimed she suffered personal injuries after the vehicle braked suddenly along Holland Road.
The claimant, Yvonne Chen Qianyun, was travelling as a fare-paying passenger when a chicken entered the path of the vehicle ahead, causing its driver to brake. The defendant, Tan Teng Kiat, then applied his brakes to avoid a collision.
Chen argued that the defendant had failed to maintain a safe following distance, forcing him to make an abrupt and forceful stop. Alternatively, she argued that the force and manner of his braking exceeded what was reasonably necessary.
The defendant accepted that he owed her a duty of care but maintained that he had sufficient time and distance to brake and had not acted negligently.
The court considered Rule 67 of the Highway Code, which requires drivers to allow at least one car length for every 16km/h of speed to ensure they can stop within the available distance.
The defendant said he was travelling at about 50km/h and maintaining a distance of approximately 10m from the vehicle ahead. The judge observed that this appeared shorter than the recommended following distance of about three car lengths.
However, the judge noted that the two vehicles did not collide, suggesting that the actual distance might have been underestimated or that any shortfall was slight. He found it unnecessary to make a definitive finding on the issue because it did not determine whether the defendant had breached his duty of care.
The judge found that the defendant had more likely than not applied an emergency or hard brake, given how quickly the events unfolded. The chicken appeared suddenly, prompting the vehicle ahead to brake almost immediately, leaving the defendant with little time to react.
He considered it unrealistic to expect the defendant to have applied normal brakes in those circumstances, noting that it was a natural and reasonable response for a driver to brake hard when the vehicle ahead did the same to avoid an immediate hazard.
The judge also referred to a scenario in the second edition of Motor Accident Guide, which addresses a public transport driver suddenly braking to avoid an animal crossing the vehicle’s path. Under that scenario, the driver bears no responsibility if there is a reasonable explanation for the sudden braking.
The claim was dismissed, with Chen ordered to pay the defendant costs fixed at SGD15,000, together with applicable goods and services tax and reasonable disbursements.
Chen was represented by Raj Singh Shergill and Koh Jia Min Desiree of Lee Shergill LLP, while the defendant was represented by Tay Boon Chong Willy of Willy Tay’s Chambers.
This is an unofficial case summary prepared by LexBru for informational and educational purposes only. It has not been reviewed, approved or endorsed by the Singapore Courts. Please refer to the full judgment https://www.elitigation.sg/gd/s/2026_SGDC_363
published on the Singapore Courts website for the Court’s full grounds of decision.
