Court reinstates drivers’ compensation claim

LexBru

The Intermediate Court has reinstated a compensation claim brought by two motorists against the estate of a deceased driver and another defendant, ruling that an earlier settlement involving injuries suffered by a passenger did not prevent the motorists from pursuing their own separate claims.

Judge Pengiran Hajah Masni Pengiran Haji Bahar delivered the judgment on October 31 in Civil Suit No. 5 of 2022, allowing an appeal by Mohammad Ali bin Othman and Haji Muhammad Razif bin Haji Ibrahim against the striking-out of their claim.

The action was brought against the estate of the late Mastadi bin Wahid and Aisah binti Salleh. Mastadi, who died before the proceedings, was named as a defendant through his estate and was not personally taking part in the action.

The dispute arose from a road traffic collision on January 10, 2019, involving a car driven by Mastadi and another driven by Mohammad Ali.

Following the accident, the estate of Mastadi and Aisah had brought High Court Civil Suit No. 48 of 2021 against Mohammad Ali and Haji Muhammad Razif over injuries and losses suffered by Mastadi’s son, who was a front-seat passenger in the vehicle.

That earlier claim was settled by a consent order on March 7, 2023 for BND460,000, without any admission of liability.

However, Mohammad Ali and Haji Muhammad Razif had already commenced their own separate action on January 4, 2023, seeking damages for their own injuries and losses arising from the collision.

The defendants sought to have the claim struck out, arguing that it was barred by the principles of res judicata and the rule in Henderson v Henderson, and amounted to an abuse of process because the earlier proceedings had already been settled.

The Registrar struck out the claim under Order 18 rule 18(1)(d) of the Rules of the Supreme Court. The two plaintiffs appealed against that decision.

In allowing the appeal, the judge found that the two actions concerned distinct claims. The earlier proceedings related to injuries and losses suffered by Mastadi’s son, while the present action concerned the injuries and losses claimed by Mohammad Ali and Haji Muhammad Razif themselves.

The court also found that the consent order in the earlier proceedings, which was made without an admission of liability, did not amount to an adjudication of the issues in the present claim.

As the plaintiffs had commenced their action before the earlier settlement was reached, the court found no basis to conclude that their claim had been extinguished or was an abuse of process.

The court therefore set aside the striking-out order and reinstated the claim. The judgment did not determine liability for the accident or the damages claimed, which remain to be decided in the proceedings.

The appellants were also awarded the costs of the appeal, to be taxed if not agreed.

Hajah Zalwatul Sakinah Haji Ibrahim of Messrs Rashid & Sim Advocates and Solicitors represented the appellants, while Sa’adtun Naadhiyah Mohammad Rosli of Messrs CCW and Partnership represented the respondents.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top