Court of Appeal dismisses bid to challenge amendments in company dispute

LexBru

The Court of Appeal has dismissed an application for leave to appeal against decisions allowing amendments to a defence and counterclaim, including claims of unjust enrichment and fraudulent misrepresentation, in a long-running company dispute.

In a judgment dated November 2, Justice Michael Lunn dismissed the application after finding that the applicants had failed to meet the threshold for permission to appeal against the earlier decisions.

The application arose from High Court Civil Suit No. 39 of 2021 and was heard on October 21 and 23 under Court of Appeal Motion No. 8 of 2025.

The dispute involves Mahadeer Mohamed and Nasreen Jaya Sdn Bhd as the first and second plaintiffs, against Ubayathullah Haja Mohideen, Zainah binti Haji Muhammad, Awangku Muhammad Dinie Hazwan bin Pengiran Haji Sahari, Sri Azlina Sdn Bhd, Standard Chartered Bank and Gallant Sdn Bhd as the respondents.

In the original proceedings, Ubayathullah Haja Mohideen was the plaintiff, while Mahadeer Mohamed and Syed Isak Mohammad Ali were defendants.

The dispute concerns the beneficial ownership of Nasreen Jaya Sdn Bhd, which operated a business selling hardware and household goods from premises in Jalan Madang, Manggis Dua.

The plaintiffs alleged, among other matters, that money was withdrawn from their bank accounts through forged cheques in July 2017, and that business documents, cash and stock were subsequently removed from their premises. They also alleged that a resignation letter and directors’ resolution bearing a forged signature were used to remove Mahadeer as a company director and appoint another individual.

Ubayathullah, however, maintained that he was the company’s sole beneficial owner, having acquired its shares in 2012 and subsequently transferred them to Mahadeer and Syed Isak as nominees.

The central issue before the Court of Appeal concerned an amendment allowed by Senior Registrar Kamaliah Ibrahim on December 10, 2024, permitting Ubayathullah and the second to fourth defendants to amend their defence to include a counterclaim.

The counterclaim sought BND313,329.22 from Nasreen Jaya Sdn Bhd on the basis of alleged unjust enrichment, including rental payments and payments made to the company’s creditors. It also alleged fraudulent misrepresentation against Mahadeer and Syed Isak, claiming they had represented that Ubayathullah was the company’s sole beneficial owner.

The amendment also resulted in Syed Isak being added as a defendant to the counterclaim.

Mahadeer and Nasreen Jaya challenged the amendment, arguing that the new claims were time-barred and that the proposed changes introduced substantial new issues into the proceedings.

A separate challenge concerned an order made by Senior Registrar Noor Amalina on April 16, 2025 directing the parties to attempt to agree on a joint expert report, with the Court able to appoint an independent expert if no agreement could be reached.

The plaintiffs argued that the direction was inconsistent with an earlier order made on August 22, 2023, which had provided for expert evidence from separate experts representing the parties.

However, the Court of Appeal found no merit in either challenge.

Justice Lunn held that the earlier decisions had been made within the respective Senior Registrars’ powers and that the case-management direction on expert evidence was intended to streamline proceedings, reduce duplication and avoid unnecessary delays at trial.

On the amendments, the Court noted that the claims concerning beneficial ownership, unjust enrichment and fraudulent misrepresentation were connected to the central dispute between the parties.

The Court also reiterated that leave to appeal against interlocutory decisions should not ordinarily be granted unless there were good reasons, such as a serious question of principle, substantial injustice or an issue of public importance.

Finding that the applicants had failed to satisfy that threshold, the Court dismissed the application.

The Court directed the parties to file written submissions on costs, limited to 1,000 words, by noon today, November 5.

On Hung Zheng and Tang Weng Leong of Messrs CCW and Partnership appeared for Mahadeer Mohamed and Nasreen Jaya Sdn Bhd.

Anlan Hee Tze Khow of Messrs Yusof Halim & Partners represented Ubayathullah Haja Mohideen and the second to fourth respondents, while Evelyn Lee Xin Yin of Messrs YC Lee and Lee appeared for Standard Chartered Bank. Gallant Sdn Bhd was unrepresented and did not appear.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top