
The High Court has dismissed an appeal by a French-based businessman seeking the return of his BND30,000 investment in a poultry farming venture, finding no grounds to overturn a magistrate’s decision that rejected allegations of gross negligence, fraud and misuse of funds.
In a judgment delivered on November 2, Judicial Commissioner Edward Timothy Starbuck Woolley dismissed Samuel Mehdi Maxime Thibault’s appeal against Easyplace Sdn Bhd, with costs awarded to the company.
The dispute arose from an agreement dated April 17, 2025 under which Thibault provided BND30,000 in capital to establish a poultry farming business with Easyplace. The profits were to be divided, with 60 per cent going to Thibault and 40 per cent to the company.
Under the agreement, Easyplace was responsible for operating the farm, purchasing a warehouse of at least 3,000 square feet, acquiring 2,000 chickens and providing adequate feed.
Thibault transferred four payments totalling BND30,000 between January and May 2025. He received BND6,567 in June 2025 as his share of the profits made by the farm, but received no further payments.
He subsequently alleged several breaches of the agreement, including failures to follow a proper feeding plan, obtain written approval for expenses, distribute profits, consult him on new employees and warehouse construction, and maintain proper financial records.
He also raised concerns over the fate of 2,034 chicks purchased for the farm. He was informed that 200 had died and 1,613 had been slaughtered and sold, leaving 221 chickens unaccounted for.
The High Court acknowledged that the company had failed to maintain adequate and comprehensive written accounts, describing this as a genuine grievance for Thibault.
However, Judicial Commissioner Woolley agreed with the magistrate’s assessment that the documentary evidence showed total expenditure of BND34,414.60 in establishing the farm. He found no basis to suggest that Thibault’s investment had not been wholly spent on the project.
The court also considered clause 12.1 of the agreement, which provided for the return of the investment if the business failed due to gross negligence, fraud or misuse of funds.
The judge found that the problems encountered were largely the natural outcome of an unsuccessful business that was probably not well managed. However, there was no evidence establishing gross negligence, fraud or misuse of funds under the agreement.
He further found that Thibault had not raised any new factual or legal arguments on appeal that would justify interfering with the magistrate’s findings.
The magistrate’s order requiring Easyplace to pay BND14,000 to Thibault was therefore affirmed, as neither party had appealed against that award.
The appeal was dismissed with costs to Easyplace.
Thibault appeared in person, while Easyplace was represented by its director, Phang Jan Kho.
The appeal was heard on October 31 before Judicial Commissioner Edward Timothy Starbuck Woolley.
