
The Court of Appeal has dismissed an application by a Bangladeshi businessman against a five-year prison sentence, BND50,000 in fines and six strokes of the cane for human trafficking offences involving three Bangladeshi workers brought to Brunei Darussalam.
The appeal by Mahedi Hassan was dismissed on November 7 by Chief Justice Dato Seri Paduka Steven Chong, Justices of Appeal Michael Lunn and Edward Timothy Starbuck Woolley, following a hearing on October 27.
Hassan had pleaded guilty to three charges involving the recruitment and receipt of Bangladeshi nationals through deception for the purpose of exploitation through forced labour.
The first two charges were under section 4 of the Trafficking and Smuggling of Persons Order, 2004, while the third was under section 5(1) of the Anti-Trafficking in Persons Act, Cap. 230.
The offences involved three men who had been promised employment in Brunei, including work as a plumber, security guard, waiter or workshop assistant, with salaries ranging from BND600 to BND875 a month.
However, after arriving in Brunei, they were placed in low-paid construction or menial work, or left without employment. Hassan retained their passports and demanded monthly payments of between BND50 and BND100, allegedly under the false claim that the payments were required by law. He also threatened to report them to the authorities or have them repatriated if they failed to comply.
The High Court had sentenced Hassan on November 6, 2025 to four years’ imprisonment and a BND20,000 fine for each of the first two charges, with 20 months’ imprisonment in default of each fine, and two strokes of the cane for each charge.
For the third charge, he received four years’ imprisonment, a BND10,000 fine with 10 months’ imprisonment in default, and two strokes.
The prison terms were ordered to run concurrently, except for the final year of the sentence for the third charge, which was to run consecutively. The strokes were cumulative, resulting in an aggregate sentence of five years’ imprisonment, BND50,000 in fines, 50 months’ imprisonment in default of payment and six strokes.
In his appeal, Hassan challenged the substantial fines, the consecutive portion of the prison sentence and the cumulative strokes. He also argued that the delay in prosecuting him should have been treated as a mitigating factor and that there was no proper basis to conclude he could afford the fines.
The Court of Appeal found no merit in the arguments.
On the fines, the court noted that Hassan had been represented by counsel during sentencing and had made lengthy written and oral mitigation submissions. However, no submission had been made that he was unable to pay the fines, and no evidence of financial inability was presented to the Court of Appeal.
The judges said the sentencing judge was therefore entitled to proceed on the basis that Hassan’s ability to pay was not an issue.
The court also upheld the consecutive one-year portion of the prison sentence, finding it appropriate when the totality of his offending was considered. It further found that the fines, default imprisonment terms and six strokes were appropriate.
On the issue of delay, the court noted that the offences occurred between 2018 and 2019, but complaints were not received by the authorities until 2021. Hassan was not located until October 2023 and was charged in February 2025.
The court also observed that the delay argument had not been raised before the sentencing judge and that Hassan had not identified any specific prejudice arising from it.
Hassan was represented by Haji Mohammad Daud Haji Ismail and Sheikh Ahmad Wa’ez Haji Sheikh Aubid of Messrs Daud Ismail & Company.
The Public Prosecutor was represented by Deputy Public Prosecutors Hajah Siti Mu’izzah Haji Sabli and Syazwani Jumat.
